Send your CV

    Attach a CV (Accepted file types: pdf, doc, docx, rtf.)

    Apply for

    The Search Report: Should You Accept a Counteroffer? 7 Questions to Ask Before Deciding

      Attach a CV (Accepted file types: pdf, doc, docx, rtf.)

      Submit Vacancy

        Attach a Job Spec (Accepted file types: pdf, doc, docx, rtf.)

        Get Talent Alerts

          Your Details

          Specialisms

          Transport & Logistics

          Distribution & Warehousing

          Customs & Freight Forwarding

          Procurement & Supply Chain

          Technology & Digital Transformation

          Seniority Levels

          Entry-Level & Junior Roles

          Mid-Level Roles

          Senior Roles

          Director & Executive Leadership

          Locations

          England

          Northern Ireland

          Republic Of Ireland

          Scotland

          Wales

          You’ve handed in your notice.

          You’ve accepted a new opportunity.

          Then your current employer makes you a counteroffer.

          Suddenly, the decision doesn’t feel quite so simple.

          Maybe they’ve offered you more money.

          Maybe they’ve promised a promotion.

          Maybe they’ve said they’ll finally address the issues that made you want to leave in the first place.

          Before you make a decision, take a step back.

          Ask yourself why you were looking to leave in the first place.

          Here are seven questions worth asking.

          1. Why did I want to leave?

          This is the most important question.

          Before the counteroffer appeared, something made you start looking elsewhere.

          Maybe it was salary.

          Maybe you felt there was nowhere left to progress.

          Maybe you weren’t enjoying the culture or management.

          Maybe you wanted a new challenge.

          Whatever the reason, be honest with yourself.

          Has that reason actually disappeared?

          If it hasn’t, a higher salary may only delay the same decision.

          2. Has the underlying problem actually changed?

          A counteroffer can make things feel different immediately.

          More money can feel like a solution.

          A promised promotion can feel like recognition.

          But ask yourself whether anything fundamental has changed.

          If you were frustrated by a lack of progression, has your employer actually created a clear career path?

          If you were unhappy with the culture, what is realistically going to change?

          If you wanted a new challenge, will your current role suddenly provide one?

          A counteroffer can change the offer. It doesn’t necessarily change the job.

          3. Is the counteroffer solving the problem or just increasing the salary?

          Money matters.

          There’s nothing wrong with accepting a better financial package if that’s genuinely what you wanted.

          But if salary wasn’t the reason you started looking, ask yourself why an increase should change your decision now.

          A counteroffer can sometimes feel like your employer has suddenly recognised your value.

          But consider why that recognition only came once you were leaving.

          Would you have received the increase or promotion if you hadn’t handed in your notice?

          That’s worth thinking about.

          4. Are the promises realistic?

          Counteroffers can involve more than money.

          You might be promised:

          • A promotion
          • More responsibility
          • Training
          • Better working conditions
          • Changes to your role
          • A review of your position

          These things sound positive.

          But before accepting, ask yourself:

          What exactly has been promised, and when will it happen?

          If the promise is vague “we’ll look at it” or “things will change”  you need to consider how likely that change actually is.

          A genuine career opportunity should have a clear path attached to it.

          5. Would I still want to leave without the counteroffer?

          This is a simple question that can tell you a lot.

          Imagine your employer had simply accepted your resignation.

          Would you still be excited about the new opportunity?

          Would you still want the new challenge?

          Would you still believe it was the right move for your career?

          If the answer is yes, ask yourself whether the counteroffer has genuinely changed your situation  or whether it has simply made leaving more difficult.

          6. Where do I want to be in 12 months?

          Don’t make a career decision based entirely on what happens this week.

          Think ahead.

          Where do you want your career to be in a year?

          Do you want more responsibility?

          A different environment?

          New skills?

          A management opportunity?

          A different sector?

          A better work-life balance?

          Then ask which option is more likely to get you there.

          The highest salary today isn’t necessarily the opportunity that gives you the strongest career tomorrow.

          7. Who can give me an independent second opinion?

          Sometimes you need someone outside the situation.

          Your current employer has a reason for wanting you to stay.

          The business offering you the new role has a reason for wanting you to join.

          Both sides have an interest in the decision.

          A recruitment consultant can provide another perspective.

          At GRN Search, if you’re considering a counteroffer on a role we’re recruiting for, talk to us before making your decision.

          We’re not there to tell you what you should do.

          We can talk through the offer, understand what originally motivated you to move and help you consider whether the counteroffer actually addresses those reasons.

          Sometimes, that second opinion can be valuable.

          Counteroffers can inflate market salaries

          Counteroffers can also contribute to rising salary expectations across the market. When employers offer significant increases to retain experienced employees, it can reset what those candidates  and others with similar experience expect to earn when considering their next move. For employers, this can make an already competitive candidate market even more expensive.

           

          Counteroffers aren’t always the wrong decision

          It’s important to say that accepting a counteroffer isn’t automatically a bad decision.

          If your employer genuinely addresses the reason you wanted to leave, offers a realistic progression opportunity and gives you a package that reflects your value, staying may be the right choice.

          But don’t let the immediate excitement of a pay rise make the decision for you.

          Look at the bigger picture.

          Why did you start looking?

          What has actually changed?

          And which opportunity gets you closer to where you want your career to be?

          Before you decide, ask yourself one final question:

          If my employer hadn’t made a counteroffer, would I still want to leave?

          If the answer is yes, don’t ignore that feeling.

          And if you’re unsure, talk it through with GRN Search.

          A good recruitment partner shouldn’t just help you find your next role.

          They should help you make the right decision about it.

           

          Back to Blog

          Other Posts...

          The Search Report: Customs Recruitment in Northern Ireland: Why Specialist Knowledge Is Becoming More Valuable
          The Search Report: Customs Recruitment in Northern Ireland: Why Specialist Knowledge Is Becoming More Valuable

          10th September 2026

          The Search Report: The True Cost of Leaving a Logistics Vacancy Unfilled
          The Search Report: The True Cost of Leaving a Logistics Vacancy Unfilled

          4th September 2026

          The Search Report: Salary Isn’t Everything: What Logistics & Supply Chain Candidates Actually Want
          The Search Report: Salary Isn’t Everything: What Logistics & Supply Chain Candidates Actually Want

          27th August 2026